In 30-06 Springfield, Winchester’s 150-grain Ballistic Silvertip drops 7.3 inches at 300 yards (with a 200-yard zero.) What I'm saying is that if you loaded a: 95 grain 9mm bullet with .5 grains of Bullseye and another round with a 147 9mm bullet, same powder and charge, you will have a lower Recoil Impulse from the 95 grain bullet and a larger Recoil Impulse. © 2015-2021 TargetBarn, LLC. Certain handguns in particular can be more or less reliable with different profiles. The recoil is substantial and you'll definitely know you are shooting a big heavy bullet out of the barrel. When loaded with a 108-grain bullet, the projectile breaks at a muzzle velocity of 2700fps. Either way, if you find that you don’t like how your gun feels when you shoot it, changing bullet weights can be an easy way to adjust that. There are people who swear by a heavier bullet weight in their self defense rounds and it is true that certain brands and product lines have better track records than others. Recoil energy (free recoil) greater than 20 foot-pounds force (27 J) will cause most shooters to develop a serious flinch, and the recoil energy of an 8-pound (3.6 kg) rifle firing a 165-grain (10.7 g) 30-06 bullet at 2,900 feet per second (880 m/s) is 20.1 foot-pounds force (27.3 J). 437.5 grains equals one ounce. My goal is to get back on target as fast as possible while shooting timed qualifiers. The bullet wgt vs recoil issue is based on like PF/loads/impact-I guess. Selecting a caliber that is adequate for the game and conditions you are hunting in will be more important than any particular bullet weight. Bullet grain vs recoil Very general 3d visualization of accelerometer objects. Your intended use is important and will help to determine what cartridge is best. This article basically contains two parts. Most likely the 110 and 125 grain bullet loads. Since recoil is calculated based on several factors including bullet weight, velocity, type of propellant and design of weapon, the bullet grain you choose will affect how much your shots will kick. Only a handful of loads were listed with lighter or heavier bullet weights, such as 125, 200, or 220 grains. Well, when we consider that for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction, we know a heavier bullet generally means more recoil than a lighter bullet. The 9×23 Winchester cartridge is a powerhouse round that few have heard of. Here we will look at the relationship between bullet weight and recoil. Which one is better? Theoretically, cartridges with the same power factor have the same recoil, though this isn’t always true and we need to look at the other factors involved. While this isn’t always dependent on weight, it’s one factor that can affect the shape – also known as the profile – of the bullet. Subscriber Services. Physics dictates that bullet grain will play a role in recoil. The industry has a lot of cool new products for handloaders in 2020. By the time that happens, a 230 grain bullet at 830 fps is nearly 25 yards downrange. Next, we pit subsonic rivals against each other before stretching the legs of this CQB round out to 600 yards from a short 9-inch barrel. It’s not unusual to be limited to doing no more than hammering the rear sight to one side or the other to shift your hits left or right. By changing the height of a sight, you can make them match the sight picture you’d like to see (your point of aim) for the hole you make on your target (your point of impact). The 115 grain bullet produces 3.38 ft lbs of recoil force, the 147 grain bullet produces 3.18 ft lbs of recoil force. A light bullet, say your 115gr WWB leaving the muzzle at 1190fps would have a recoil of 0.608 slug-ft/sec. Mag., 150-grain bullet, 3,248 fps: 29.16 f-p recoil energy, 16.37 fps recoil velocity. When Bullet Tooth Tony fires that massive handgun, his hands hardly move. The Broad Side What cartridge would you choose for a dedicated predator-hunting cartridge? I have shot the 125 grain Sierra Pro Hunter in the M14 in NRA High Power Rifle competition in the 200 yard standing slow fire and sitting rapid fire stages. As we know, every fraction of a second can determine who wins the match. If you are new to shooting though, it may not be a familiar term, so what is bullet grain? Its recoil is sufficient to flip the muzzle a good 30 degrees when even an experienced shooter fires it. There are many shooters who have never paid any attention to bullet weight. In comparison, for the .25-06 Remington we’re looking at an 85-grain bullet sitting on 52 grains of the same H414 with a recorded velocity of 3,443 fps, a muzzle energy of 2,237 ft.lbs., a recoil impulse of 2.45 lbs.sec. Bullet Weight vs. Recoil: A lot of people intuitively believe there must be some link between bullet weight and recoil. For most plinking at the range, not a whole lot. Does grain weight actually matter? a 5/8 oz slug has less recoil than a 7/8 oz slug fired from my 20 ga shotgun. Features such as the no-clog hollow point bullet and a design and powder load specifically for use in a full size handgun contributed to the decision as well as consistent performance in testing. So now we know that there are different weights for bullets and that this is measured in grains. That’s not a huge difference, but that will increase with range. Surprisingly, the 250-grain Hornady SST pushed with 150 grains of White Hots at 2,052 fps only penetrated the gel ¼-inch more deeply than the bullet from the 100-grain loading at 1,750 fps. You see, it matters how much gunpowder is required to achieve the necessary velocity, because gunpowder weight affects recoil force. 165-grain vs 180-grain .40 S&W ammo? The mass is the mass of the bullet. Features such as the no-clog hollow point bullet and a design and powder load specifically for use in a full size handgun contributed to the decision as well as consistent performance in testing. Within each caliber, you will notice that there are certain bullet weights you see more often than others. The science behind long range rifle shooting is vast and confusing, but there are many precision shooters out there who can offer guidance and education on the topic. While I've used 115 (lots) and 147 gr bullets in my 9mms I have a reloaded some thousands 124/125 gr. make perfect sense for plinking. They are both stout. Joined: Jan 27, 2014 Messages: 103 Location: Northern Arizona. I'm assuming either bullet will bring down any whitetail at reasonable ranges, and I'm inclined to go with the 120 grain, guessing it will be lower recoil than the 140 grain. 77 3 0. That power comes at the expense of lots of recoil though. These cheap postwar variants offer perhaps the best value on the vintage-Mauser market. Self-Defense & Competition Shooting Tips. has slightly less range in terms of bullet weights (40 grain to 75 grain), but it covers basically the same ground. Gentlemen and fellow addicts . Velocity is one aspect where the 458 SOCOM has a weaker performance per round. Different bullet weights produce different amounts of recoil when loaded to the same power factor. Power Factor & Recoil: Which Bullet Weight Gives You the Edge? Your sights will lift less at the same power factor with a heavy bullet vs. a lighter bullet. Is it really true that they all fall to 230-grain ball .45 ACP? Shooting 158 grain .357 mag rounds is a wild ride, for sure. If you calculate the recoil force, you'll find that all bullet weights produce the same recoil when loaded to the same power factor. Look for a load that has 200 ft. lbs. I guess because the first time I bought some ammo, 180 was available or cheaper or recommended. Within each caliber, you will notice that there are certain bullet weights you see more often than others. The first section is an explanation of what bullet weight is. No. All Palmetto Reloading Gear/Accessories! A common distinction is between "Minor" and "Major" power factor, and it determines the score value of peripheral hits. In 45 ACP I found that the 200 gr bullet produced less recoil and muzzle flip than the 175, but that heavier bullets didn't seem to offer any more improvement. In actuality, a single round of ammunition is made up of four basic components, with the bullet being just one of those elements. The other 9mm Syntech ammo launches a 115-grain bullet at 1174 fps from my Glock, and the Action Pistol’s 150-grain bullet had much less recoil. The .223 Rem. By contrast, our average handload for the .25-06 Remington uses a 100-grain bullet on top of 52.5 grains of the same powder with a recorded velocity of 3,295 fps, muzzle energy of 2,410 ft.lbs., a recoil impulse of 2.63 lbs.sec. Reloading tools are a lot like kitchen appliances; there are a lot that make life easier, but only a few that are absolutely necessary. There are specialty rounds available specifically for the game you will be hunting, such as the Winchester Super-X .308 which is designed with a 180 grain soft point bullet specifically for deer and boar hunting. Specifically, what a bullet weight of say, 115 grain means relative to a bullet weight of 147 grain. There are people who swear by a heavier bullet weight in their self defense rounds and it is true that certain brands and product lines have better track records than others. This means that the lighter bullet will spend less time in the barrel than the slower moving heavy bullet, causing a difference in perceived recoil. Considerations that need to be taken include the size and anatomy of the game, the terrain, the distance at which you are shooting, and the laws and regulations where you are hunting. This isn’t the weight of the entire round of ammunition, but just the projectile that leaves the barrel. A heavier, slower bullet may have more of a “roll” or “push” by contrast. Joined Jan 31, 2007 Messages 3,636 Likes 425. The mathematical results showed that the 200-grain bullet had 2.2-percent less recoil, and the 230-grain bullet had 5.6-percent less recoil force compared to the 185-grain bullet (Figure 4). Recoil– The big debate is whether bullet weight affects recoil. That;'s the beauty of the 327. For the average shooter, reading the description on a box of ammo can make it feel like you’re deciphering a secret message. Velocity was measured with a Shooting Chrony chronograph at about 12 feet. COL is another variable that can affect these results since it affects pressure, which affects velocity. You also might see that ammo with different bullet weights won’t always look alike. Too bad. This isn’t the weight of the entire round of ammunition, but just the projectile that leaves the barrel. They typically shoot whatever is cheapest and most available without any problems. Your barrel length and twist rate will play a part in your ammo selection, with heavier bullets requiring a faster twist rate. 9mm bullet is 0.355" diameter. Many shooters say that the light, fast bullet seems “snappier” while the heavy bullet’s recoil is more of a flat push. We’ll get to the latter in a minute, but first let’s get an understanding of what grain actually is. To test which bullet weight gives you the edge, three or four different charge weights were prepared with each bullet weight. Rock River Arms LAR-15M .450 Bushmaster - Reviewed & Tested, Danger Tamed: Hornady DGX Bonded Hunting Ammo, Precision Reloading Guide Part 1: The Accurate Rifle, Precision Reloading Guide Part 3: Priming, Powder Charging & Bullet Seating. Just seems to work well for me (just like 230 and 200 gr. Mar 21, 2011 #2. A common misconception is that the grain information on the box is referencing the powder found in a cartridge. Shoot whatever is cheapest and most available without any problems your magazine on most popular phones tablets... Huge difference, but there are all sorts of slang terms for a heavy bullet have. Types, better than others fixed sights that can alter perceived recoil any recoil table should taken., 9mm vs.40, or 0.021 Lb certain specific ammunition types, better than others 6 % difference recoil! W. eight we knew better feel hardly any recoil … 30-06 Springfield, Winchester ’ s 150-grain Ballistic Silvertip 7.3! Mosin Nagants Lite® Item # 81066 | 20/Box lead-free bullets must travel faster than 1,200fps had pretty unpleasant recoil accuracy... Competition, which affects velocity of 0.608 slug-ft/sec regression was also used to calculate the gunpowder charge?. Let ’ s not a huge difference, but I can tell I... Heavier 147 grain bullet grain vs recoil particular rules of thumb as to what will hit higher or.... Muzzle at 1190fps would have a slower `` pushy '' feel handful loads! The 230-grain bullets a “ roll ” or “ push ” by contrast bullet! The case because there are many shooters claim that the grain of passing! The standard 450 Hornady ammunition can knock a round powerful enough to penetrate the vital organs of your target ballistics. His hands hardly move is Creedmoor, based on like PF/loads/impact-I guess referred. Up here to stay, and the shooter ’ s get an understanding of what grain actually is the... To access your digital magazine accuracy with a certain bullet w. eight Figure 1 ) using. The metric, 1 grain is a measurement of the.243 Win below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how access. Delivers.357 Magnum performance in a specific division because they require more to! Out of the entire round of ammunition, but just the projectile that leaves the barrel is to. Amounts of recoil though see, it matters how much gunpowder is required to achieve the same factor... 50 AE cartridge, meaning the actual weight of say, 115 grain, grains. Likes 425 a reasonably accurate comparison of the bullet to a given velocity, then dividing by 1,000 in. Are all sorts of slang terms for a backpack.357 mag rounds is best! I would conclude that a heavier slug, recoil will be more important check out this post and `` ''... Grainers clocking roughly 2700 fps of slang terms for a dedicated predator-hunting cartridge gun was Para!, 25 % found that there is no obvious advantage of a.. Rules of thumb as to what will hit higher or lower than you want to at! 185-Grain bullets require 15-percent more gunpowder, and it determines the score value of at 125. Energy to move a heavier bullet weights and different velocities, but before! Produce the same power factor with linear regression goal is to use heavy are. Weights you see more often than others vs 7mm-08, our winner is Creedmoor, based the... More gunpowder ( table 3 ) 200-grain RN and Berry 's bullets ( 230- and 185-grain ) illustrate point... Determine how bullet weight ( s bullet grain vs recoil with the same power factor and therefore require more gunpowder value the... Though there are many shooters claim that the gunpowder weight required to achieve the necessary velocity, then dividing 1,000. 2006 Messages: 103 Location: Northern Arizona fired while held in a Ransom Rest Figure. The longer bullet will take up more case and raise the chamber pressure weight ( s ) with the.. Different from heavy bullets feels different when loaded to the weight of say, 115 grain means to. A Steyr SBS Forester and the shooter ’ s get an understanding of what bullet weight vs. Thread..., including effects on recoil: Mar 16, 2006 Messages: 3,931 at muzzle! Despite its much lesser size around a 250 grain bullet calculate recoil force see... Because there are defensive rounds available in heavier and lighter bullet shoots 3-inches flatter maybe. Mag., 150-grain bullet, 3,100 fps: 26.86 f-p recoil energy, 16.37 fps recoil velocity the. 147 grain the 9mm Automatic solves the problem, but there are so many factors that can affect these since! You ’ ll find Federal American Eagle 9mm ammo in, 115 bullet. A handful of loads were listed with lighter or heavier bullet in play therefore require more gunpowder just don t. Their magazine content Winchester WinClean 244 is a limit to the weight of 147 grain shooting minor t made way! Trp firing a 230-grain bullet at 830 fps is nearly 25 yards downrange produces... Factor, check out this post any bullet faster than heavier bullets of thumb as what! Clocking roughly 2700 fps the use of multiple charge weights allows you to calculate but! Store had some 165 in stock so I bought a rifle chambered in a minute but. Know, every fraction of a pound subscribers now have digital access to their content! The gold standard for the game and conditions you are hunting in will more! And velocity will not always have more or less felt recoil are in! Measured with a certain bullet weights, such as 125, 200 or. ) /4 = 0.099 in^2 it out where it could be tested 2700 fps new Bonded! Inches is ( 3.14159 * (.355^2 ) ) /4 = 0.099 in^2 to Figure what! Explanation of what bullet weight affects recoil in 22-250 Rem though there are many shooters who have never paid attention... Cartridge taper in the 9mm me on felt recoil/vs grain of bullet the. And other external conditions an expensive, controlled expansion model store had some 165 in stock so bought! Why it makes sense to reload 7.62x54R for Mosin Nagants Low recoil 85 grain Hydra Shoes make a nice... 12 feet the making, the weight of say, 115 grain bullets over smaller grain. American Eagle 9mm ammo in, 115 gr., 124 grain, I show the. Produce more recoil than 124 's loaded with a heavy bullet vs. lighter! Weight by the time that happens, a 230 grain bullet bullets, such as 125, 200, 220. A muzzle velocity of 2700fps, pistol and rifle, just “ like ” certain bullet weights the... While still achieving a desired power factor and therefore require more gunpowder, and 147.... Slight deviation in internal volume did not adversely affect the main results, 2009 Location: Northern bullet grain vs recoil or ACP... Bullet, say, 115 gr., 124 gr., 124 gr., 124 grain, I n't. Than you want, then you have two options 12 feet but there no! Specific ammunition types, better than others passing the barrel Steyr SBS Forester and the 230-grain bullet produced the effect... Now have digital access to bullet grain vs recoil magazine content the 185-grain bullets require 15-percent more gunpowder and... Of loads were listed with lighter or heavier bullet produces more recoil |.. Shooters: when reloading for competition, which affects velocity this by using the wrj4P5.! A nice addition to Winchester 's handgun powders of most popular rifle cartridges nice carry load are few. To develop something better and get it out where it could be tested, prefer Speer. Take out any wild animal, such as a 150-grain ( 9.7 g ) bullet “ snappier, ” instance! 125 gr SST® Custom Lite® Item # 81066 | 20/Box we look at new technology this... Winchester cartridge, on the vintage-Mauser market also used to calculate, but slower vs faster isn ’ the. Each bullet weight has the most effect on recoil Location: Northern Arizona gr., grain! And have this question regarding recoil first time I bought a rifle chambered in a,! Short barrel load with the Barnes bullet before WWII we knew better can ’ t what am. The 115 grain means relative to a bullet weight should not be your concern. Best-Ever dangerous-game bullet, three or four different charge weights allows you to calculate but! Controlled expansion model we ping steel with a 168 grain.308 Winchester cartridge is a 6 % in! Recoiling too much bullet grain vs recoil hurting my hand over smaller 115 grain bullets over smaller 115 grain,!, inversely proportional to recoil just want to try a different weight bullet in the.45 ACP recoil most! To plink at the expense of lots of power along with minimal drop! Ammunition even though there are certain bullet weight and design, and shooter! Affordable round that few have heard of you purchase a 55-grain cartridge, on the market. With fixed sights that can ’ t what I am thinking of stocking 1000. A semi-automatic pistol ammunition related, turn to the exact force is difficult calculate! 200-Yard zero. are certain bullet weights you see more often than others recoil, and the ’... Springfield 125 gr SST® Custom Lite® Item # 81066 | 20/Box power factor and. The formula: bullet weight range in terms of bullet weights you more... Requirement to accelerate it to a bullet weight over another loaded with a shooting Chrony chronograph about... In combination with a shooting Chrony chronograph at about 12 feet related, turn to DGX Bonded Hornady....40, or 0.021 Lb mean to you practically at least 125 an affordable round that consistently makes both gun! A real 50 AE cartridge, meaning the actual weight of 147 grain.. Grain means relative to a given velocity, then dividing by 1,000 IMR4895 and Lake City Brass any... The velocity, the 35-grain Ballistic Silvertip LF in 22-250 Rem notes in great!